42-38157   FOUR FREEDOMS

MACR 3550
(Also listed as MACR 3657)
1LT
JOHN J PESCH
PILOT
RTD
2LT
J C AMLEY
CO-PILOT
RTD
2LT
ORRIN F WEBB
NAVIGATOR
POW
2LT
ARTHUR J RUBENSTEIN
BOMBARDIER
POW
TSGT
EDWIN M EDWARDS
ENGINEER
POW
SSGT
JAMES F ROUSE
RW GUNNER
POW
TSGT
COLE SAGE
RADIOMAN
POW
SSGT
WILLIAM G JAMISON
LW GUNNER
POW
SSGT
WINFORD P BIDWELL
BT GUNNER
POW
SSGT
GRADY SEARCY
TAIL GUNNER
POW
Mission #21 Target: Brunswick
March 23, 1944
March 28, 2005
History in Blue
Falling Fortress: After crew bailed, two remained to steady B-17
By Robert F. Dorr
Special to the Times

When John Pesch finished his World War II combat duty in August 1944, a military document
summarized his contribution as a B-17 Flying Fortress pilot.

Pesch had flown 31 missions, the document said, “the majority of which were deep
penetrations in which he was flying as lead pilot. On several occasions his plane was shot
up badly, and on one occasion he brought the ship back with two motors out and with all
crewmembers except his co-pilot having bailed out.”

Today, the retired major general is 83 and lives in Sterling, Va. During the war, he frequently
flew as a pathfinder for bomber formations on raids to German cities such as Berlin, Munich
and Schweinfurt - all defended by anti-aircraft batteries and fighters.

Pesch was born in 1921 in Queens, N.Y., and worked for an aircraft company before
enlisting in 1942. After training in flying class 43-C, he flew A-24 Dauntless dive-bombers
and A-20 Havoc attack planes at stateside bases before becoming a founding member of the
452nd Bombardment Group. He went to England as a pilot in the group’s 731st
Bombardment Squadron.

Pesch was a captain March 23, 1944, when German fighters shot out two engines on the left
side of his B-17 during a bombing raid on Brunswick, Germany. Amid the hectic struggle for
survival that followed, eight crew members bailed out, leaving Pesch alone with his co-pilot,
1st Lt. J.C. Amley.

Pesch never gave the order to bail out. “Years later,” he said, “my navigator told me that
when the aircraft passed through 11,000 feet almost upside down and at an airspeed of 325
mph, he knew in his heart that we two pilots were dead and the rest of the crew would soon
be dead, too.”

The navigator opened the nose hatch and bailed out. The engineer saw this and opened the
bomb bay doors. The rest of the crew jumped. Eight crew members parachuted safely to
earth and became prisoners of war for the remainder of the conflict.

Pesch and Amley had difficulty regaining control of the B-17 because control surfaces were
shot away, but by bracing their knees against the control column, they were able to regain
straight and level flight.

“Ground fire would have destroyed our aircraft except for the appearance of a lone P-51
[Mustang],” Pesch said. “The pilot of the P-51 came alongside, flew our left wing and gave
us a thumbs-up. He strafed the sites of the ground fire and effectively escorted us to the
English Channel. Amley and I owe our lives to that P-51 pilot. We tried to locate the pilot
later but were not successful. Whoever he is, he is our hero.”

Pesch’s co-pilot, Amley, is now deceased. In a Web site about the 452nd Bombardment
Group, his son, Chris Amley, describes the stress of two men struggling to save a plane
intended for a crew of 10. “My mother told me Dad’s wedding ring cracked under the force
he used on the control yoke,” he wrote. “Dad ... never wanted to pilot a plane after
returning from his tour of duty.”

After that mission, Pesch returned to combat in B-17s. He served a full career and became
head of the National Guard Bureau before his military retirement in 1977.

Robert F. Dorr, an Air Force veteran, lives in Oakton, Va. He is the author of books on
military topics, including “Chopper,” a history of helicopter pilots. His e-mail address is
robert.f.dorr@cox.net.


**********************************************************************************************************************************
The original crew of this plane recognized being fortunate to live in the United States and
enjoy the four basic freedoms bestowed to every citizen 1) The freedom of speech and
expression everywhere in the world. 2) The freedom of every person to worship God in his
own way everywhere in the world. 3) The freedom from want--which, translated into world
terms, means economic understandings which will secure to every nation a healthy
peacetime life for its inhabitants--everywhere in the world. 4) The freedom from fear--which,
translated into world terms, means a world-wide reduction of armaments to such a point and
in such a thorough fashion that no nation will be in a position to commit an act of physical
aggression against any neighbor--anywhere in the world. The crew was not so sure of the
last freedom while flying combat missions! They named the plane Four Freedoms while they
were still training in the States and had the name written on the nose. John J. Pesch was
the original pilot.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
The pictured aircraft was a Boeing B-17 Flying Fortress named "The Four
Freedoms," part of the 452 Bombardment Group stationed at Deopham Green. In
March 1944, the group took part in a raid on Brunswick. Capt. John Pesch, of
Maspeth, New York was pilot. Lt. J.C. Amley of New Richland, Minnesota, was
co-pilot.
En route to the target, the formation was attacked by enemy fighters."The Four
Freedoms" suffered extensive battle damage, including loss of two engines,
ailerons, and left landing gear. One of the waist gunners was struck in the head
by an enemy shell. Due to the damage, the Fortress was unable to keep up with
the other aircraft. Despite this damage, the crew continued the mission, reaching
the target, and completing the bomb run alone.

After the bomb run, Pesch, believing the aircraft to be in grave danger, gave the
order for the crew to bail out. He and Amley stayed at the controls while the
others jumped. At some point, the plane lurched. Amley and Pesch braced their
knees against the control column to stablize the aircraft.

Finally, Pesch motioned for Amley to jump, but Amley refused. After a short
discussion, the two pilots agreed to try to return to England (or to die trying)
believing that it would take both of them to keep the plane under control.
Eventually, as you can see, they landed somewhere in East Anglia, dazed but
alive.

According to Pesch's wife, his wedding ring cracked under the force he used on
the control yoke. Pesch was 25 years old when these events took place. He
passed some years ago. He never wanted to pilot a plane after returning from his
tour of duty.